Stair Tread Replacement

Fort Erie, ON

Worn, paint-spattered white stair treads replaced with stained grey-brown oak to match the house flooring. The white handrail and turned spindles remain, with matching oak plank at the bottom landing.

Worn paint-spattered staircase with white spindles before replacement
Staircase with new grey-brown oak treads beside a white spindle railing
BeforeAfter

Drag the handle, or focus it and use the arrow keys, to compare before and after.

We replaced the worn painted treads on a straight staircase in a private home with new wood treads and matching risers. The white spindle railing stayed, and the stairs now tie into the grey plank floor at the bottom.

Project type
Oak Stair Treads
Location
Fort Erie, ON
Photos
3 from the job site
Scope
Worn painted stair treads replaced
Finish
Grey-brown wood treads with matching risers
Kept
White spindle railing, newel post and handrail
Service
Interior finish carpentry

From first look to final reveal.

Select a stage to jump to its photos.

  1. Worn paint-spattered staircase with white spindles before replacement
    01BeforeWorn, paint-spattered white treads
  2. Staircase with new grey-brown oak treads beside a white spindle railing
    02AfterStained oak treads beside the retained white railing

Painted stairs, worn through

The before photo shows a full flight of stairs with white-painted treads worn down to bare wood across the middle. Scuffs, stains and a rust-coloured mark ran up the steps where people walk. The risers and the white spindle railing were in better shape.

Paint on stair treads wears fastest right where your feet land, and repainting only buys a short time. New treads fix the surface for good and change the look of the whole hallway.

Worn paint-spattered staircase with white spindles before replacement
Worn paint-spattered staircase with white spindles before replacement

New treads and risers

The crew prepared the existing stair structure and installed new wood treads with a grey-brown tone and a rounded front nosing. Matching risers close in each step, so the flight reads as one continuous finish from top to bottom.

Each tread has to sit tight to the wall on one side and the stringer on the other. Small gaps show up fast on a staircase you look straight up, so we fit and check every step before fastening it down.

We also paid attention to the bottom step. It meets the hallway floor, so its height and colour have to sit right against the planks around it.

Close-up of new oak stair treads meeting the oak-floored landing beside a white newel post
Close-up of new oak stair treads meeting the oak-floored landing beside a white newel post

Keeping the railing

The turned white spindles, newel post and handrail were sound, so we kept them and cleaned up the edges where they meet the new treads. Keeping a good railing saves money and keeps the character of the house.

White stringers and spindles against the darker treads give the stairs a crisp outline. At the bottom, the tread colour lines up with the grey plank flooring in the hall.

Staircase with new grey-brown oak treads beside a white spindle railing
Staircase with new grey-brown oak treads beside a white spindle railing

What to know before you redo your stairs

Decide first whether you want the treads to match your floor or contrast with it. Matching tone makes a small hallway feel bigger. A contrasting tread makes the staircase a feature.

Tell us at the quote visit if you want to keep your railing. That choice shapes the scope more than any other. We check the spindles, newel and handrail for looseness before we plan around them.

Staircases get used every day, so plan for the time the stairs are out of use. We work in a sequence that keeps the stairs passable for as long as possible and talk through the plan with you before we start.

Questions about this project.

Something else on your mind? Ask us directly.

Can you replace stair treads without replacing the railing?

Yes. On this staircase we kept the white spindle railing and newel post and replaced the treads and risers around them. We check the railing for loose parts first.

Should stair treads match the floor?

They do not have to. Matching the tone of the floor at the bottom of the stairs makes the space feel continuous. A contrasting tread makes the staircase stand out. Bring flooring samples to the quote visit if you are unsure.

Is it better to repaint worn stairs or replace the treads?

Paint on treads wears through where people step, often within a year or two of regular use. New wood treads hold up much longer and change the look of the staircase.

Planning something like this?

Tell us what you have in mind. We visit the property, look at the space with you, and put together a free quote based on what we actually see.

More about our services

See the whole property